1 IS AVAILABLE
$319.00 
MS 62
1 IS AVAILABLE
$929.00
MS 60
1 IS AVAILABLE
$118.00
MS 63
1 IS AVAILABLE
$469.00
MS 63
1 IS AVAILABLE
$879.00
AU-55
1 IS AVAILABLE
$230.00
XF-40
1 IS AVAILABLE
$485.00
MS 64
1 IS AVAILABLE
$112.00
VF-25
1 IS AVAILABLE
$282.00
VF-25
1 IS AVAILABLE
$192.00
MS 64
1 IS AVAILABLE
$396.00
MS 66
| Description | Year | Price | Grade | Seller | Offers | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 |
1913 Type 1 Buffalo Nickel, Gem Uncirculated, PCGS MS-65, Frosty | 1913 | $224.00 | Tipsico Coin LLC | No | |
 |
1913-S Type One Buffalo Nickel, PCGS/CAC MS-62, Original BU Coin, LOW CAC Pop | 1913 | $319.00 | MS 62 | Tipsico Coin LLC | No |
 |
1913-S Type Two Buffalo Nickel, ANACS MS-60, Certified Key Date | 1913 | $929.00 | MS 60 | Tipsico Coin LLC | No |
 |
1913 Type 2 Buffalo Nickel, Choice Uncirculated PCGS MS-63 | 1913 | $118.00 | MS 63 | Tipsico Coin LLC | No |
 |
1914-S Buffalo Nickel, Choice Extremely Fine, Edge Clip | 1914 | $125.00 | Tipsico Coin LLC | No | |
 |
1914-S Buffalo Nickel, PCGS MS-63, Flashy and Original | 1914 | $469.00 | MS 63 | Tipsico Coin LLC | No |
 |
1914-S Buffalo Nickel, Choice Almost Uncirculated+, Better Date | 1914 | $185.00 | Tipsico Coin LLC | No | |
 |
1914 BUFFALO 5C | 1914 | $14,850.00 | PR 68 | Rare Coin Wholesalers | Yes |
 |
1914-S BUFFALO 5C | 1914 | $38,500.00 | MS 67 | Rare Coin Wholesalers | Yes |
 |
1915-S Buffalo Nickel, Key Date, PCGS/CAC AU-55, Very Tough | 1915 | $879.00 | AU-55 | Tipsico Coin LLC | No |
 |
1915-D BUFFALO 5C | 1915 | $12,100.00 | MS 67 | Rare Coin Wholesalers | Yes |
| |
1916-D Buffalo Nickel, Extremely Fine | 1916 | $77.00 | Tipsico Coin LLC | No | |
 |
1916 Buffalo Nickel, Choice Uncirculated, Original BU Coin | 1916 | $100.00 | Tipsico Coin LLC | No | |
 |
1917 Buffalo Nickel, Choice Uncirculated, Original | 1917 | $195.00 | Tipsico Coin LLC | No | |
 |
1918-D BUFFALO 5C | 1918 | $47,500.00 | MS 62 | Rare Coin Wholesalers | Yes |
 |
1918-D Buffalo Nickel, About Very Fine, Tougher Semi Key Date | 1918 | $75.00 | Tipsico Coin LLC | No | |
 |
1918-D Buffalo Nickel, Extremely Fine, PCGS XF-40, Better Date | 1918 | $230.00 | XF-40 | Tipsico Coin LLC | No |
 |
1920-D BUFFALO 5C | 1920 | $47,300.00 | MS 66 | Rare Coin Wholesalers | Yes |
 |
1920-D BUFFALO 5C | 1920 | $27,500.00 | MS 66 | Rare Coin Wholesalers | Yes |
 |
1920-S BUFFALO 5C | 1920 | $49,500.00 | MS 66 | Rare Coin Wholesalers | Yes |
 |
1921 Buffalo Nickel, PCGS MS-64, Tougher P Mint Date | 1921 | $485.00 | MS 64 | Tipsico Coin LLC | No |
 |
1923-S Buffalo Nickel, Very Fine+, PCGS VF-25, Original | 1923 | $112.00 | VF-25 | Tipsico Coin LLC | No |
 |
1923-S Buffalo Nickel, Uncirculated Details, Discounted | 1923 | $495.00 | Tipsico Coin LLC | Yes | |
 |
1923-S BUFFALO 5C | 1923 | $27,500.00 | MS 66 | Rare Coin Wholesalers | Yes |
 |
1924-S Buffalo Nickel, Better Date, PCGS VF-25, Original and Problem Free | 1924 | $282.00 | VF-25 | Tipsico Coin LLC | No |
 |
1925 Buffalo Nickel, Choice Uncirculated | 1925 | $95.00 | Tipsico Coin LLC | No | |
 |
1925-D BUFFALO 5C | 1925 | $12,000.00 | MS 66 | Rare Coin Wholesalers | Yes |
 |
1926-S BUFFALO 5C | 1926 | $77,000.00 | MS 65 | Rare Coin Wholesalers | Yes |
 |
1926-S BUFFALO 5C | 1926 | $77,000.00 | MS 65 | Rare Coin Wholesalers | Yes |
 |
1927-D BUFFALO 5C | 1927 | $23,500.00 | MS 66 | Rare Coin Wholesalers | Yes |
 |
1931-S Buffalo Nickel, Choice Uncirculated, PCGS MS-64, Flashy BU | 1931 | $192.00 | MS 64 | Tipsico Coin LLC | No |
 |
1935-D Buffalo Nickel MS66 NGC | 1935 | $680.00 | MS66 | Park Avenue Numismatics | No |
 |
1936 D Buffalo Nickel MS65 PCGS | 1936 | $169.00 | MS 65 | Talos Numismatics | No |
 |
1936-S Buffalo Nickel MS67 PCGS | 1936 | $1,180.00 | MS67 | Park Avenue Numismatics | No |
 |
1936 S Buffalo Nickel MS64+ CACG | 1936 | $129.00 | MS 64+ | Talos Numismatics | No |
 |
1936 Buffalo Nickel MS66 PCGS GSH | 1936 | $219.00 | MS 66 | Talos Numismatics | No |
 |
1937-D BUFFALO 5C | 1937 | $23,000.00 | MS 65 | Rare Coin Wholesalers | Yes |
 |
1937 Buffalo Nickel MS65 NGC | 1937 | $89.00 | MS 65 | Talos Numismatics | No |
 |
1937 S Buffalo Nickel MS66 PCGS Toning | 1937 | $179.00 | MS 66 | Talos Numismatics | No |
 |
1937 Buffalo Nickel MS66 NGC OH | 1937 | $99.00 | MS 66 | Talos Numismatics | No |
 |
1937-D BUFFALO 5C | 1937 | $23,000.00 | MS 65 | Rare Coin Wholesalers | Yes |
 |
1937 Buffalo Nickel MS66 PCGS | 1937 | $106.00 | MS 66 | Talos Numismatics | No |
 |
1937 D Buffalo Nickel MS65 PCGS | 1937 | $98.00 | MS 65 | Talos Numismatics | No |
 |
1937 S Buffalo Nickel MS65 PCGS | 1937 | $106.00 | MS 65 | Talos Numismatics | No |
 |
1937-D BUFFALO 5C | 1937 | $52,250.00 | MS 66 | Rare Coin Wholesalers | Yes |
 |
1938 D/D Buffalo Nickel MS66 PCGS Toning | 1938 | $179.00 | MS 66 | Talos Numismatics | No |
 |
1938 D/D Buffalo Nickel MS66 NGC | 1938 | $149.00 | MS 66 | Talos Numismatics | No |
 |
1938 D Buffalo Nickel Overmintmark FS-515 MS66 PCGS | 1938 | $396.00 | MS 66 | Talos Numismatics | No |